Paasa Logo

Wealth Protection

Do GIFT City Funds Avoid US Estate Tax?

How US estate tax applies to GIFT City fund units and to US stocks bought through a GIFT City broker, and how both compare with US ETFs and UCITS ETFs.

Abhighyan Sinha

Abhighyan Sinha

It depends on what you own. If you hold units of a fund set up in GIFT City, you own units of an Indian IFSC fund, not shares of a US company, so the units are generally not US-situs assets. If you buy US stocks through a broker in GIFT City, you still own US shares, and those are US-situs and count toward the $60,000 limit for US estate tax.

Table of contents

Why does it matter what you own?

US estate tax for a non-resident applies only to US-situs assets, and for shares, situs follows the company that issued them. Under Section 2104(a) of the US tax code, shares held by a non-resident who is not a US citizen are US property only if they are issued by a domestic (US) corporation.

So what matters is whose shares or units you hold, not where your broker sits or which exchange you used. A US company's shares are US-situs wherever you hold them. Units of a fund set up outside the US are a different asset, even when the fund invests in US companies.

For a fuller list of what counts, read US-situs assets.

Do GIFT City fund units count for US estate tax?

Generally, no. A GIFT City fund is set up in the International Financial Services Centre at Gandhinagar and regulated by the International Financial Services Centres Authority (IFSCA). When you invest in it, you hold units issued by that fund, and the fund itself owns the US shares or US ETFs.

Because the units are not shares issued by a US corporation, they do not count toward your $60,000 US-situs total. The fund's own US holdings belong to the fund, not to you.

Note: GIFT City fund units and US stocks bought through a GIFT City account can sit side by side in the same app, so the two are easy to confuse. Check whether you hold units of a GIFT City fund or shares of US companies, because only the fund units stay outside US estate tax.

Do US stocks bought through a GIFT City broker count?

Yes. When a broker in GIFT City buys shares of Apple or Microsoft for you, you own shares issued by a US corporation. Section 2104(a) treats those shares as US-situs, and the broker's location does not change that.

Buying US stocks through a GIFT City account does not take the shares out of US estate tax. If your US shares, US ETFs and US broker cash together are worth more than $60,000 when you die, your estate may owe US estate tax of up to 40% on them.

How do the routes compare?

Only the routes that give you units of a non-US fund stay out of US estate tax. Here are the four common routes for an Indian resident who wants US market exposure:

Route What you own US-situs? Counts toward $60,000
US stocks through a GIFT City broker Shares of US companies Yes Yes
US-listed ETFs (for example, an S&P 500 ETF listed in New York) Units of a US-domiciled fund Yes Yes
GIFT City fund units Units of an IFSC fund in India Generally no No
Ireland-domiciled UCITS ETFs Shares of an Irish fund No No

Example

Suppose you are an Indian resident with $200,000 invested in the S&P 500, and you are comparing three ways to hold it.

Route US-situs value US estate tax on death
US-listed S&P 500 ETF $200,000 $41,800
GIFT City S&P 500 fund investing through a UCITS ETF $0 $0
Ireland-domiciled S&P 500 UCITS ETF $0 $0
Difference between the US ETF and either alternative $41,800

The result: holding the same index through a US-listed ETF could leave your estate owing about $41,800 in US estate tax, while the GIFT City fund and the UCITS ETF keep that exposure out of your US-situs total. The US ETF figure is the tentative tax of $54,800 on $200,000, less the $13,000 credit for non-residents. You can check other amounts with Paasa's US estate tax calculator.

What are the trade-offs of GIFT City funds?

GIFT City funds solve the estate tax problem for the units you hold, but they come with trade-offs worth weighing before you invest:

  • Fewer funds to choose from. The range of GIFT City funds is far smaller than the range of UCITS ETFs listed in Europe.
  • An extra layer of costs. A GIFT City fund that invests through an underlying fund charges its own fees on top of the underlying fund's fees.
  • LRS still applies. GIFT City is in India, but resident Indians invest in GIFT City funds by remitting money under the Liberalised Remittance Scheme, so the $250,000 yearly limit and the bank paperwork apply, just as they do for UCITS ETFs.
  • Less control. You hold one fund's units, so you can't pick individual stocks or rebalance across markets inside that holding.

For a fuller comparison of costs, tax and access, read UCITS ETFs vs GIFT City outbound funds.

Where do UCITS ETFs fit?

UCITS ETFs give you the same US market exposure without US estate tax, and a much wider choice of funds. A UCITS ETF tracking the S&P 500 is a share in an Irish fund, so it is not US-situs, whichever broker you hold it with.

UCITS ETFs also have a dividend advantage. An Ireland-domiciled fund pays 15% US withholding tax on US dividends inside the fund under the Ireland-US tax treaty, compared with the 25% withheld from an Indian investor on a US-listed ETF. With an accumulating share class, there is no dividend income to report in India each year.

If you already hold US stocks or US ETFs, the next question is whether to switch, and what that costs. Read how to avoid US estate tax for every option compared, or US estate tax for Indians for the full rules.

About Paasa

Paasa is a global investing platform for Indian residents and NRIs. It gives you direct access to stocks on their home exchanges in the US, Canada, the UK, Germany, France, Switzerland, the Netherlands, South Korea, Japan, Hong Kong and Singapore, along with ETFs and UCITS funds.

  • A wide UCITS range: Choose from UCITS ETFs and UCITS mutual funds across US, global, emerging market and bond exposures, in USD, GBP, EUR and other trading currencies.
  • Direct ownership: Hold UCITS ETFs and individual stocks directly in an account in your own name, instead of through a single fund's units.
  • Know your exposure: Use the US estate tax calculator to see what your current US-situs holdings would cost your heirs, and plan any switch to UCITS from there.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do GIFT City funds avoid US estate tax?

Units of a GIFT City fund are issued by an IFSC fund in India, not by a US company, so they are generally not US-situs assets and do not count toward the $60,000 limit for US estate tax.

Are US stocks bought through GIFT City subject to US estate tax?

Yes. US stocks bought through a GIFT City broker are still shares of US companies, so they are US-situs assets and count toward the $60,000 limit for US estate tax, wherever the broker is based.

Is a GIFT City fund better than a UCITS ETF for US estate tax?

A GIFT City fund that invests through UCITS ETFs and an Ireland-domiciled UCITS ETF both keep the holding out of US estate tax. The difference is in choice, cost and control: UCITS ETFs offer a much wider range of funds, while a GIFT City fund that invests through an underlying fund adds a layer of fees.

Do I need LRS to invest in GIFT City funds?

Yes. Resident Indians invest in GIFT City funds by remitting money under the Liberalised Remittance Scheme, so the $250,000 yearly limit and the usual bank paperwork apply.

Does the location of my broker affect US estate tax?

No. US estate tax looks at who issued the shares, not where the broker is. Shares of a US company are US-situs whether you hold them through a broker in the US, in GIFT City or anywhere else.

Discussion

Disclaimer

The information provided in this post is for general informational purposes only. It is not intended as professional advice or to replace consultation with qualified professionals. While we strive to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the information presented, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability, or availability with respect to the content contained herein. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk. We disclaim any liability for any loss or damage, including, without limitation, indirect or consequential loss or damage, or any loss or damage whatsoever arising from loss of data or profits arising out of, or in connection with, the use of this post. Always seek the advice of professionals or relevant authorities regarding your specific situation or circumstances.

Share this article
Get started

Build wealth in dollars, safeguard against rupee depreciation

Book a short call with our team to understand how Paasa can work for you