Atlas by Paasa

The RSU Holder

If part of your pay comes as company shares, you're already a global investor, whether you meant to be one or not. This module is built specifically for RSU holders. It walks through the full lifecycle of an RSU from grant to sale, how it is taxed, and the problems unique to them.

Understanding RSUs - Part 2

Before anything else, you need the vocabulary and the shape of an RSU's life. This chapter covers what an RSU actually is, how it differs from a stock option, the three moments, grant, vesting, and sale, and the mechanics of vesting schedules, forfeiture, and sell-to-cover.

2.1

What is an RSU?

RSU stands for Restricted Stock Unit. It is a promise from your employer to give you a certain number of company shares in the future, provided you stay and meet certain conditions. You are promised the shares, but you cannot have them yet; they are restricted until you have earned them over time.

Two features distinguish RSUs from other kinds of equity pay. First, you pay nothing for them. Unlike stock options (ESOPs), where you must pay a price to buy the shares, RSUs are simply given to you as part of your compensation, at no cost. Second, until they convert into real shares, an RSU is only a bookkeeping entry, a unit, not a share. It has no market value you can access, you cannot sell it, and you do not receive dividends or votes on it.

2.2

Grant, vest, sale: the three moments

An RSU's life has three distinct moments.

  1. Grant. This is the day your employer promises you the shares, usually when you join or as part of an annual award. The grant specifies how many units you are getting and the schedule on which they will convert to shares.
  2. Vesting. This is the moment when units convert into actual shares, and those shares are deposited into a brokerage account in your name. From this point, you are a genuine shareholder of the company, free to hold or sell.
  3. Sale. At some later point you sell the shares, for cash, triggering a sale event.

All of the steps above have significance for your portfolio and taxation considerations, which we'll unpack in this chapter and the ones that follow.

image.png
2.3

Three stages, two tax events

Here is the single most useful thing to fix in your mind before anything else. An RSU passes through three stages, but it is taxed at only two of them.

At grant, nothing is taxed, since the income is not yet generated. It is a tax non-event. At vesting, the first tax hits: the moment your units convert to shares you own, the value of those shares is treated as income, essentially as part of your salary, and taxed accordingly. This happens whether or not you sell anything.

At sale, the second tax hits: any gain in value since vesting is taxed as a capital gain, a separate tax from the first, on a different thing, the growth after vesting rather than the value at vesting.

2.4

The vesting schedule

Between grant and vesting sits the vesting schedule, the timetable that decides when your units convert to shares. The most common arrangement at large tech companies is a four-year schedule with a one-year cliff.

A cliff means that for the first year, nothing vests at all. If you leave before your one-year anniversary, you walk away with nothing from the grant. But on that first anniversary, a large chunk vests all at once, typically a quarter of the whole grant. Each company treats the vesting schedule differently based on internal policies and priorities which is why the grant is worth reading carefully the day you receive it: how many units, on what schedule, with what conditions.

2.5

Forfeiture: what you lose if you leave

The flip side of the vesting schedule is forfeiture. Because you earn RSUs by staying, leaving early means giving up what you have not yet earned. Shares that have already vested are yours to keep. But any units that have not yet vested are generally lost the moment you leave the company. They simply return to the employer.

2.6

Vesting in practice: becoming an owner, and sell-to-cover

Vesting in practice: becoming an owner, and sell-to-cover

Vesting is where the lifecycle becomes active, because a tax bill is triggered immediately, on the value of those shares, and it usually has to be paid straight away. This creates a practical problem: you have just received shares, not cash, but you owe tax. Where does the money come from?

The common answer is a mechanism called sell-to-cover. Under sell-to-cover, your employer sells a portion of the shares, right at vesting, and uses the proceeds to pay the tax on your behalf. A slice is sold off the top to cover the tax, and the rest lands in your account.

With the lifecycle now clear, we turn next to the mechanics of taxation for RSU holders.

Key takeaways from this chapter

  • An RSU is a promise of free shares; you pay nothing to receive them.
  • Grant, vesting, and sale are the three stages, but only two are taxed.
  • A typical vesting schedule runs four years with a one-year cliff.
  • Unvested units are generally forfeited if you leave the company.
  • Sell-to-cover automatically sells a portion of vested shares to fund the tax due.

Ready for a quick knowledge check?

One question. Less than 10 seconds. Reinforce what you've learned before continuing to the next chapter.

Share this chapter

Discussion